← All posts

Investing & portfolio

Best Sectors in a Recession and How Big Investors Shift

Which sectors do best in a recession or slow economy?

Defensive sectors, such as consumer staples, healthcare and utilities, usually fall less in a recession because people keep buying food, medicine and electricity whatever the economy does. Cyclical sectors, such as banks, travel, autos and luxury goods, usually fall more because spending on them is easy to postpone.

Defensive does not mean safe. In almost every downturn nearly every sector falls; defensive ones simply tend to fall less and recover steadily. The goal is a smaller drawdown and the ability to keep investing, not a gain. This article explains the pattern, shows real numbers, describes how large investors behave and gives you a plan.

Key terms: what do these recession words mean?

A few terms used throughout this article.

  • Recession: a broad, sustained fall in economic activity, often seen as shrinking output, rising unemployment and falling spending.
  • Defensive sector: a sector whose demand stays fairly steady in bad times, such as staples, healthcare and utilities.
  • Cyclical sector: a sector whose earnings rise and fall strongly with the economy.
  • Drawdown: the fall from a peak to a later low.
  • Rebalancing: selling what has grown and buying what has fallen to return to your target mix.
  • Sector rotation: moving money between sectors as the economic cycle changes.
  • Stagflation: slow growth combined with high inflation, which hurts both stocks and bonds.

Why do defensive sectors fall less than cyclical ones?

The reason is demand. Households cut holidays, new cars and restaurant meals before they cut groceries, prescriptions and electricity, so defensive companies see steadier sales and often keep paying dividends. Cyclical companies also carry fixed costs and borrowed money, so a modest fall in sales can cause a large fall in profit, which is why their shares fall more.

Markets also look ahead. Prices usually fall before the economy turns down and often start rising before it recovers, so by the time a recession is officially announced, much of the fall may already have happened.

How did sectors actually perform in 2008?

In calendar 2008, the US stock market (S&P 500) fell roughly 37%, and from its October 2007 peak to the March 2009 low it fell roughly 55%. Approximate 2008 sector returns show the pattern clearly. These are rounded figures to show the ordering, and exact numbers differ by index and data source.

  • Consumer staples: about -15%
  • Healthcare: about -23%
  • Utilities: about -29%
  • Consumer discretionary: about -34%
  • Industrials: about -40%
  • Technology: about -43%
  • Financials: about -55%

Why was 2022 different from 2008?

In 2022 the slowdown was driven by inflation and rising interest rates rather than a banking crisis. The S&P 500 fell about 18% and growth shares and long bonds fell hard together, while energy rose by roughly 60% or more and staples, utilities and healthcare were about flat. Bonds, which cushion a typical recession, fell because rates were rising.

The lesson is that the best sectors depend on the cause. In a demand-driven recession, defensive sectors and government bonds usually help. In an inflation-driven slowdown, energy, commodities and real assets can do better, and bonds may not protect you. This is why holding several types of assets matters more than picking one defensive sector.

Which sectors should you hold more or less of?

A practical way to think about it:

  • Usually hold up better: consumer staples, healthcare, utilities, and high-quality large companies with low debt and steady cash flow.
  • Mixed: technology and communication services, where strong firms with cash can hold up but expensive, unprofitable ones can fall hard.
  • Usually hit hardest: banks and financials, real estate, autos, travel, luxury and industrial cyclicals.
  • Outside equities: high-quality government bonds often rise when growth fears push interest rates down; gold often does well in fear; cash gives flexibility.

How do big investors behave during a recession?

Large investors mostly follow rules rather than predictions. Pension funds and endowments set target weights, for example 60% stocks and 40% bonds, and rebalance when markets move. That means they buy stocks after a fall, when it feels worst, and sell after a rise.

Some hold large cash reserves so they can buy when others must sell; Berkshire Hathaway has held hundreds of billions in cash and short-term bills for this reason. Multi-asset funds, such as risk-parity or all-weather styles, spread money across stocks, bonds, gold and commodities so that no single economic outcome sinks the whole portfolio.

What they usually do not do is sell everything and wait for the bottom. Timing the exact low is extremely hard, and missing the first strong rebound can cost more than the fall avoided.

What does rebalancing look like with real numbers?

Start with 100 split 60 in stocks and 40 in bonds. Stocks fall 30%, so they become 42, and the total is 82. Stocks are now about 51% of the portfolio, below your 60% target.

To restore 60%, you need 49.2 in stocks (60% of 82), so you move 7.2 from bonds to stocks. Later, stocks recover by 43% (42 back to 60 is +42.9%). The rebalanced portfolio has 49.2 x 1.429, about 70.3, in stocks plus 32.8 in bonds, about 103.1 in total. Without rebalancing you would only be back at 100. The extra 3.1 comes from buying stocks while they were cheap.

Many investors use a band rule: rebalance only when an asset drifts more than 5 percentage points from its target, or once a year, whichever comes first. This avoids constant trading and keeps costs and taxes low.

Why does a big fall need an even bigger rise?

Losses and gains are measured against different bases. The formula is recovery needed = 1 / (1 - fall) - 1. After a 10% fall you need +11%; after 20%, +25%; after 30%, +43%; after 40%, +67%; after 50%, +100%; after 60%, +150%; after 70%, about +233%.

Recovery time also varies. The US market took about five and a half years to regain its October 2007 peak, around seven years after the March 2000 peak, but only about five months after the February 2020 crash. This is why limiting the size of the fall with diversification can shorten the time to recover, and why a long horizon and steady investing matter.

How can you buy in stages during a downturn?

Suppose an asset is at 100 and you keep 10,000 in reserve. You buy 2,500 after a 10% fall (price 90), 3,500 after a 20% fall (80) and 4,000 after a 30% fall (70). You hold about 128.7 units at an average cost of about 77.72.

Your break-even is 77.72, only 11% above the lowest price and 22% below the original 100. If the price recovers to 100, the position is worth about 12,867, a gain of about 28.7% on the 10,000 even though the asset only returned to where it started. The risk: if it keeps falling or never recovers, you lose more because you invested more, so only use money you can leave alone and assets you believe will survive.

How much cash should you keep for a recession?

Keep an emergency fund of three to six months of essential expenses outside your investments, and up to twelve months if your income is irregular or in a cyclical industry. If your monthly essentials are 2,000, that is 6,000 to 12,000.

The fund stops you from selling investments at the bottom to pay bills. Beyond it, some investors hold an extra buffer of cash or short-term bonds to buy in stages if prices fall. Pay off high-interest debt first: clearing a 15% loan is a guaranteed 15% return that no sector can match.

What mistakes should you avoid in a slow economy?

Most damage comes from reacting to fear.

  • Selling everything after a big fall and missing the recovery.
  • Moving all your money into one 'safe' sector that may already be expensive.
  • Using borrowed money to invest, which can force you to sell at the worst time.
  • Ignoring debt: paying down high-interest loans is a guaranteed return.
  • Stopping regular investing; monthly investing buys more units when prices are low.
  • Assuming the last recession's winners will win again, as 2008 and 2022 show.

Try it: plan for a downturn in Eyrie

Use the Asset allocation calculator to build a mix with stocks, bonds, gold and cash for your risk level, and the Drawdown planner to plan staged buying and see the recovery needed at each level. To see how long a recovery takes at a given return, use the CAGR calculator.

Is this investment advice?

No. This article is for education only and is not investment, tax or legal advice. Past behaviour of sectors does not guarantee future results, figures are rounded and illustrative, and you can lose money. Consider your own situation or speak to a licensed adviser before making changes.

Frequently asked questions

Which sector is best during a recession?

Consumer staples, healthcare and utilities usually fall less because demand is steady, but no sector is immune and results vary by recession.

Should I sell my stocks before a recession?

Timing is very hard and markets often recover before the economy does. Many investors rebalance to a target mix and hold an emergency fund instead of selling everything.

Do bonds and gold help in a recession?

High-quality government bonds often rise as interest rates fall, and gold often rises in fear, but neither is guaranteed. In inflation-driven slowdowns like 2022, bonds fell too.

What do big investors do in a downturn?

Most follow rules: rebalance to target weights, keep cash to buy when others sell, and spread money across stocks, bonds, gold and commodities.

How much emergency fund do I need for a recession?

Three to six months of essential expenses is typical, and up to twelve if your income is irregular or tied to the economy.

Get new posts in your inbox

We email you whenever a new post goes live. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Track your portfolio with Eyrie

Get the Android app to manage holdings, trades and market research in one place.

Comments

Likes and comments coming soon